Supreme Court Examines Legal Grounds of Meenakshi Natarajan's Rajya Sabha Nomination Challenge

Hyderabad: During a hearing on Friday, the Supreme Court raised pointed questions about the legal merit of Congress leader Meenakshi Natarajan's challenge to the dismissal of her Rajya Sabha nomination, marking a critical juncture in the proceedings.
The judges sought clarification from senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi regarding any established precedent where the Supreme Court has stepped in to address disputes over nomination rejections. The Bench further noted that election law frameworks already contain designated remedies available to candidates facing nomination dismissals, and emphasized the judiciary's circumscribed role in such matters.
Presenting Natarajan's case, Singhvi contended that authorities had not initiated any First Information Report against his client. He informed the court that no judicial body had registered cognisance of the complaint underlying the nomination rejection. According to Singhvi's submissions, Natarajan had only received a preliminary notice from the authorities.
The senior counsel drew the court's attention to Section 33A of the Representation of the People Act, arguing that candidates are obligated to declare criminal matters in nomination affidavits only after a court has taken cognisance and proceeded to frame charges in cases where the prescribed punishment exceeds two years imprisonment. He requested the Bench to apply these statutory provisions while assessing the legitimacy of the nomination rejection.
The proceedings remained ongoing as of the report's filing, with the Bench having not yet pronounced its judgment.
Compare options


